Thus begins the decline of Mr. Bear’s one-on-one time with Taylor—a childhood rite of passage that is heartbreaking to witness, though Trott handles it with gentle love and care. As Taylor slowly drifts apart from Mr. Bear, he remains staunchly loyal, waiting for her return every day and dreaming of the fun things they might do together. Still, the transformation in their relationship is poignant, as Mr. Bear sits in Taylor’s bedroom on a chair, watching her “come and go” while he’s left behind, feeling “sweet and understanding but a little sad”—emotions younger readers will likely find relatable.
Trott brings this charming story full circle once Taylor has children of her own, offering readers an ending that’s as warm and fuzzy as Mr. Bear himself—though he’s now “fragile and a bit old and tired… [and] special care is required.” The understated illustrations allow Trott’s heartfelt narrative to take center stage, but they still capture Mr. Bear’s delightful facial expressions and the endearing bond he shares with Taylor. Kids—and any adult who fondly remembers the well-loved toys from their youth—will find this debut a touching ode to childhood innocence.
Takeaway: A young girl’s bond with her stuffed animal is tested as she grows up.
Comparable Titles: Loren Long’s Otis, Anna M.’s Stuffed Animals Are for Everyone.
Production grades
Cover: B
Design and typography: B+
Illustrations: B-
Editing: B+
Marketing copy: A-
