Though previous series entries work as standalone romances, and Treadgold offers context here for new readers, this climactic volume really targets readers of the whole series, structured as a family soap opera in which Edward and Lisette’s relationship is often sidelined to the follow ups for David, Maddie, and Liam’s movie pursuits, Ali and Liam’s drama about their addicted birth mother, and the return of the distasteful but still compelling yoga guru Kilo. The connection between Lisette’s past and the current O’Connell dramas overshadows the romantic story arc. Edward’s church backstory is shared almost entirely in exposition, so its emotional impact is lessened, and his disclosure of psychic predictive powers would feel more surprising if not for the family’s other supernatural gifts.
Still, the cast and holiday setting are presented with a casual mutual warmth, and the overall impression is an appealingly fuzzy one of a family coming together with love and mutual support, despite their wide disparities in life paths and backstories. Treadgold’s deep affection for her characters and understanding of their hearts, quirks, and concerns will reward fans of the series, though this entry isn’t a jumping-on point. Readers wanting more from protagonists of earlier installments get plenty of it, and overall the series comes to a satisfying conclusion.
Takeaway: Reunions, romance, and a warm holiday vibe power this series ender.
Comparable Titles: Lydia Michaels’s Almost Priest, Nora Roberts’s The MacKade Brothers series
Production grades
Cover: B
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: A
Marketing copy: A-
