Readers will be captivated by the surprising twists, unexpected alliances, and personal growth of the characters. Jack starts as a playful prankster who conceals a tender side beneath his jovial exterior. As the story unfolds, we witness Jack's character evolving subtly, lending a rich depth to the narrative. The dynamics between Jack and the other Bandits richen the at-times familiar adventure storytelling, giving readers reason to invest in the relationships, and ultimately leading to memorable transformation and growth. The boys’ joking with each other eventually gives way to them speaking frankly about some tough topics, like why Jack’s crush might not reciprocate his interest: “You’re selfish, arrogant, and judgmental,” Gene says. “It’s no wonder Sarah doesn’t like you.”

Savage's narrative style maintains a fast-paced rhythm, captivating attention from start to finish, though the rapid resolution of conflicts and dangerous incidents sometimes has the effect of diminishing the narrative stakes. One notable strength of the book is its introduction of unexpected antagonists, whose motives and intentions invite readers to guess, which adds welcome suspense and intrigue to an engaging adventure that combines memorable twists, heartfelt friendships, and personal growth.

Takeaway: Exciting treasure-hunt adventure with strong insight into friendship.

Comparable Titles: Aaron Johnson’s Mystery in Rocky Mountain National Park, Roshani Chokshi’’s Aru Shah and the End of Time.

Production grades
Cover: A-
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: A-
Marketing copy: A-