Assessment:

Plot: Gorsky creates an often vivid and vibrant YA sequel to Shakespeare's The Tempest. Despite its many fine qualities (the Mermaid Tavern is particularly refreshing), the worldbuilding and structure of the story can be somewhat chaotic and uneven in its execution.

Prose:  Gorksy has a lovely prose style that is abundantly fitting for the magical source material. 

Originality: The Tempest is an infrequent contender for modern restagings. Gorsky has a clear grasp on what makes the play unique and delightful and echoes these qualities throughout Rough Magic. 

Character/Execution: The author puts a fresh twist on the original characters from The Tempest, making them somewhat more transparent in their actions and behaviors, without reducing their mystique. 

Date Submitted: August 25, 2022