Assessment:

Plot: Hoffman’s novel is well-plotted and obviously well-researched. She also introduces a number of surprises in regards to plot, genre, and characters.  While the story progresses a bit slowly and has some occasional lulls, the narrative flows smoothly and logically. Fantastical elements are finely balanced with more realistic details.

Prose: Hoffman’s prose is full of beautiful imagery and excels at “showing, not telling.” The author doesn't shy from sometimes graphic and gut-punching moments. Told from the third-person omniscient POV, Hoffman does an excellent job of portraying the characters’ emotions through imagery and their gestures, mannerism, and actions, especially in the case of Uriel, a mute boy.

Originality: Readers will find all the elements of a classic historical fiction novel but with a twist of fantasy and the supernatural, as well as a focus on a divine, heaven endowed quest. Another element that readers will appreciate is the rich history of the Jewish people and religion woven seamlessly throughout the story.

Character/Execution: The two protagonists, Uwe, translator for the Ordnungspolizei, and Uriel, a mute Jewish boy, are extremely convincing in their roles as individuals from vastly different worlds who become allies. Uwe has the greatest character development, as he moves from a shy, quiet man to a courageous, outspoken ally of the Jewish people. Uwe and Uriel prove themselves to be truly righteous, brave, and intelligent and will steal the hearts of readers. Though antagonist Major Brandt, leader of the Ordnungspolizei, is somewhat unconvincing, secondary characters generally serve the story well and are essential to the narrative as a whole.

Blurb: A truly unique work of fantastical, historical fiction set in Nazi Germany that will keep readers engaged and invested in the characters and their fates. 

Date Submitted: June 19, 2021