Granger transports readers into Sam’s first-person narrative, offering important insight on SAD and how to treat it, along with a healthy dose of hope for those who may be struggling with the same issues. Sam’s struggles are heartbreaking to watch, but even so, his youthful explanation of how SAD impacts everyday life gifts readers with an inside view of a grueling disorder: “The worst part about SAD is that it can be lonely, so most of the time I keep it a secret. Depression is not something you can easily talk about with your friends or family.” Readers will find plenty of hands-on advice in Sam’s story too, as Granger deals with treatments ranging from light therapy to herbal remedies, all of which Sam uses to cope with feeling isolated, left out, and “down in the dumps.”
Granger’s material is heavy, and adult readers should be ready to explain the more complex topics to younger audiences, like the interplay between serotonin, dopamine, and melatonin that sometimes contribute to SAD, but Sam’s language is easy to follow and Granger’s multi-colored graphics break up the sobering text. Kids will connect with Sam’s need to “recharge” during winter—and wish to have superpowers to escape to a place of endless summer—while drawing inspiration from his willingness to open up about a disorder that too many are reluctant to share.
Takeaway: Easy-to-follow introduction to Seasonal Affective Disorder, from a kid’s perspective.
Comparable Titles: Andi Green’s Don’t Feed the WorryBug, Michael Rosen’s Sad Book.
Production grades
Cover: B
Design and typography: B
Illustrations: B
Editing: B-
Marketing copy: A