Engaging characterization grounds the adventure. Milo stands out as an authentic and sincere protagonist willing to try his best to be a hero, even if he isn’t yet sure precisely what that will look like. Sammy shines as an intelligent, caring, and kind person who looks out for his friends no matter the cost, while Kat stands out as a strong, inspirational girl tired of being underestimated and ready to blow expectations out of the park, although a softer and more loving side is shown as she grows closer to her friends. The camaraderie and brisk dialogue make this group of children engaging to follow, and readers will be sure to cheer them on as they pass through the gargoyle mists to face dangers and solve riddles together.

Quinton springs welcome surprises, too, like the Snarlok gargoyles (“the ugliest things that’s ever been dreamed of by man”), a garden gnome named Grimlo, and much ado about Moonstones. The magic and puzzles are unpredictable, the gargoyle realm continually inventive, and the story well thought-through and engaging, both rewarding and upending expectations. At times, the pacing could be more brisk, but Milo Savage and the Gargoyle Hunters will keep young readers invested throughout. This middle-grade fantasy is captivating until the very last page.

Takeaway: This middle-grade fantasy adventure will entice young lovers of adventure, riddles, and surprises.

Great for fans of: Karuna Riazi’s The Gauntlet, Kazu Kibuishi’s The Stonekeeper.

Production grades
Cover: A-
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: A-
Marketing copy: A