by Lee Wind
Plot: Wind's engaging, utterly enjoyable tale of teen self-discovery is riveting both for its well-structured, historically-based plot and its emotional honesty. Snappily paced and filled with insightful details, the story turns heteronormative culture on its head as Wyatt, the thoroughly likable protagonist, takes on a battle for historical truth that leaves his small-town neighbors clutching their pearls.
Prose: Wind’s polished prose is filled with laugh-out-loud moments, often thanks to the author’s ability to zero in on the perfect descriptive detail. But it is the dialogue that shines brightest, capturing both the insult-laden banter of teens and the awkward sincerity of the adults struggling to manage them.
Originality: In taking on this slice of Civil War-era history, Wind brings historical material into contemporary relevance in a unique and original way. The use of social media posts and transcriptions provides even more freshness and present-day appeal to the story.
Character Development: Wind provides an accurate portrayal of the coping mechanisms, unwieldy emotions, and ultimately the inner triumph of a teen struggling to make the world ready for him to come out of the closet. A resonant and admirably crafted work.
by David Heaney
Plot: Heaney demonstrates a strong grasp on storytelling for children in a tender tale that explores weighty issues of life, death, and the meaning of existence, as animal characters question how they can best fulfill their individual purposes.
Prose: Heaney’s eloquent writing expertly blends anthropomorphic details into descriptions and dialogue, causing readers to alternately forget and distinctly remember that the leading cast of this novel is comprised of furry and feathered friends.
Originality: Heaney’s middle grade novel is a unique contemporary story that pays tribute to classic works of children's literature through its poignant and sophisticated approach to dealing with questions about death, purpose, and grief.
Character Development: Heaney’s characters are quirky, sympathetic, and wise. With humor and grace, the author gently advocates for building meaningful relationships with our creature companions, our human companions, and the natural world around us.
by Sophie McAloon
Plot: Captivating from start to finish, McAloon's novel draws the reader into an exquisitely rendered world. As the story builds toward its climax, the violence increases and the stakes grow ever higher. Readers will find this nearly impossible to put down.
Prose: Tightly written and highly polished, McAloon's prose shows very fine craftsmanship; her characters' flirtatious dialogue casts a spell with its pitch-perfect blend of humor and intimacy. The author is at her best, however, when her descriptive prose lingers on the beautiful.
Originality: It takes real talent to make a YA dystopian tale feel original these days, but McAloon pulls it off and sticks the landing. And, she challenges the reader with real questions about gender, power, and violence.
Character Development: McAloon's characters quickly reveal themselves as deeply believable young adults struggling to reconcile authentic inner conflicts. Alice is relatable in her dawning awareness, and her growth unfolds with masterful precision.
Blurb: Captivating and nearly impossible to put down, McAloon's twisted but beautiful world comes alive on the page.
by Sharon CassanoLochman
Plot: This is a well-plotted adventure with plenty of tension, which will guarantee reader interest without seeming contrived.
Prose: CassanoLochman’s prose is slick and polished and flows naturally. The voice is age-appropriate and manages to effortlessly convey a host of emotions from elation to despair.
Originality: What sets CassanoLochman’s book apart from the pack is its originality in terms of setting and subject matter.
Character Development: The main protagonists are utterly likable, well developed, and engaging.
Blurb: A great coming-of-age adventure.
by David J. Naiman
Plot: Naiman’s richly developed novel follows likeable protagonist Jake as he battles his real-life and dream-world demons, and undergoes significant character growth as a result. Time travels differently in Jake’s magical-realistic, very vivid dream world, while the numerous flashbacks ground the storyline.
Prose: Naiman convincingly writes from the perspective of a child processing his grief and trauma, with authentic dialogue and fresh, funny prose.
Originality: This relatable novel offers familiar middle grade elements--the impact of bullying, social status, younger siblings--while integrating emotional and psychological complexity through the protagonist's imaginative dreamlife.
Character Development: The author crafts memorable characters that experience ample personal growth and degrees of self-realization over the course of the novel. Readers are clearly and immediately introduced to a small cast of key players who serve as guides to Jake’s waking adventures and have their own counterparts in his lucid dreamscapes.
Blurb: Naiman’s poignant coming-of-age novel offers a sensitive and honest examination of a child's spiritual and emotional battles.
by C.C. Bolick
Plot: This novel is expertly plotted. The story moves along at a good pace and will engage readers.
Prose: The prose here is inconsistent—some passages are very strong, while others fail to live up to the same high standard.
Originality: An original take on a traditional story. While some elements will be familiar to readers, the writing is fresh enough to elevate the plot—in part, because of the strong characters.
Character Development: This novel features very well rendered characters. They are the best part of this book. Jes Delaney is a sympathetic protagonist.
by Michael F. Stewart
Plot: This ably plotted and entertaining novel flies along at a breakneck pace, with the author throwing the most outrageous forms of adversity at Ray at every turn.
Prose: Stewart’s prose careens and rollercoasters on each page. The writing is thoroughly enjoyable.
Originality: Ray’s adventures are fun, wacky, and vaguely reminiscent of the Scott Pilgrim novels and the Diary of a Wimpy Kid series. Nonetheless, this story is wholly original. Young readers will be delighted.
Character Development: Ray is a fully formed and fun character. Readers will definitely get to know him and appreciate the way he changes over the course of the book.
Blurb: Stewart’s fast-paced, darkly hilarious novel will cause readers to chuckle, tear up, hug their moms, and cross their fingers for a sequel (or graphic novel adaptation) sometime in the foreseeable future.
by P. G. Shriver
Plot: This novel is absorbing and well plotted. The author grabs readers early on and then slowly reveals just enough information to keep them hooked and turning pages.
Prose: While the storyline here is very strong, the writing is less so. The prose suffers from issues relating to word choice, sentence structure, character consistency, and excessive description.
Originality: With a unique and captivating premise, this work takes readers on an unexpected journey with memorable characters. Readers of all ages will be drawn to Cheater and will want to accompany her on her quest.
Character Development: Cheater and Jaz are distinct and original, although it takes some time to get to know them and learn their histories. Readers will be drawn in by these damaged adolescents who seek answers in a cold, indifferent world.
Blurb: An intriguing plot with memorable characters, this work will captivate readers of all ages from beginning to end.
by A M H Johnson
Plot: Johnson delivers an evenly plotted coming-of-age story with an immersive setting, chilling supernatural elements, and a pervasive sense of foreboding. The story's moments of levity allow nightmarish passages greater impact.
Prose: Johnson capably establishes the novel’s rural setting through clear, vivid descriptions, while distinctive dialect provides further authenticity. Repetition and the occasional overuse of sentence constructions can detract from the otherwise sound storytelling.
Originality: While the novel is rooted in conventions of the paranormal YA genre, Johnson has a clear command of narrative and ultimately delivers a spunky and spooky outing.
Character Development: Readers will eagerly follow Johnson’s likeable protagonist as she unwittingly becomes embroiled in a decades old mystery; well-conceived side characters and allies enhance the story as Jenna discovers that she can communicate with a world beyond her own.
by T.K. Riggins
Plot: Riggins presents to readers a clever, fast-paced story that intertwines a mystery surrounding the theft of Lenia’s trident with Team Liberati’s second attempt at the Quest Series, introduced to readers in the first book, How to Set the World on Fire. Unfortunately, the conclusion of this novel leaves far too many questions unanswered for readers to be satisfied.
Prose: Riggins maintains strong pacing throughout the story, by utilizing efficient sentence structure and paying close attention to the flow of passages and reveal of information at appropriate moments.
Originality: Money Jane offers elements that mimic modern lifestyles, such as the Sage Mirrors, which introduce a refreshing vibe to a story with otherwise archaic characteristics.
Character Development: Even minor characters feel authentic in this book, but what is truly memorable is the bond between Kase and his talented buddies, Lenia and Talen. This close-knit group naturally balances their individual strengths and weaknesses into a highly plausible, dynamic friendship.
Blurb: A thoroughly entertaining YA fantasy adventure.
by Rob Shapiro
Plot: The plot of Shapiro’s novel will be familiar to genre fans, but the author does give it many lively and adventurous twists. Although the story ends somewhat abruptly, Shapiro has clearly laid the groundwork for a follow-up adventure.
Prose: Sam speaks to the reader in a voice that is believable, effective, and age appropriate.
Originality: Shapiro’s fantasy world puts a colorful and inventive gloss on traditional imaginary worlds.
Character Development: The characters in Shapiro’s novel are pleasingly quirky and well-rounded. Even the otherworldly characters they interact with have depth.
by Mark Herder
Plot: Herder belts it out of the literary ballpark with this solid novel, covering all the standard YA bases: an insecure teen narrator, sexist jocks, small-town sports rivalries, unrequited young love, a barrier-breaking girl, and the devastation of suicide.
Prose: The author's prose captures the interactions of his characters with admirable fidelity to the tone of teens; though the novel is pitched to young readers, the writing is mature enough for adults, enlivened by frequent wit.
Originality: Herder offers up an original tale of gender-barrier busting on the baseball field and adolescent high school cliques off the field.
Character Development: George and Ruth—competing as starting pitchers—are well-rounded, multi-dimensional central characters. The large cast of teammates, schoolmates, and townspeople are equally well-developed.
Blurb: Set in the world of small-town high school baseball, this is pitch-perfect storytelling.
by Robert Hill
Plot: Hill’s novel explores the sudden and mysterious death of technology and the subsequent creation of a dystopia and the inevitable reversion of human beings to old-fashioned methods and traditions, delving into darker and darker themes as the book progresses.
Prose: The language in Hill's novel drips with suspense and eerie tension, as the Strykers navigate a brave new world teeming with dangerous possibilities. However, efforts to accurately depict the young narrator’s voice can come off as forced and inauthentic at times.
Originality: Though this book will remind readers of the Twilight Zone episode “The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street” and Stephen King’s The Mist, the author does a superb job at creating the unique storyline of the Strykers’ fight for survival.
Character Development: With the death of civilization, comes the transformation of an entire community and society. Kyle Stryker is a distinct character who witnesses these unstoppable changes—and grows and changes himself over the course of the narrative.
by M Pepper Langlinais
Plot: Langlinais artfully mirrors without overly mimicking the play-within-a-play of Shakespeare's Hamlet with a storyline that is fast-paced and engagingly plotted.
Prose: The author's prose crackles with rhythmic writing and colorful similes, ably capturing young voices while gently mocking the weirdness of adults.
Originality: Though the book's plot tracks the classic play Hamlet, it does so with a great deal of fluidity and flair.
Character Development: Langlinais takes familiar YA types and invests them with refreshing resonance.
by LT Anderson
Plot: Anderson offers an often captivating and well-plotted dystopian story. Worldbuilding sections can rely too heavily on exposition, while innovative ideas have intriguing potential but can overwhelm the story. Nevertheless, Anderson presents a chilling reality marked by stark societal divisions and oppression.
Prose: Written in a commanding and hard-hitting style, Anderson's prose effectively conveys the tension and terror of a world erupting in chaos, with a doomed love affair at its center.
Originality: The narrative is evocative of past dystopian works, yet Anderson capably creates a dark and cruel multidimensional story with memorable imagery.
Character Development: Anderson presents a cast of memorable characters that expose human nature at its cruelest: power hungry and bent on genocidal annihilation. Others are vibrant and relatable, expressing an authentic range of emotional responses to trauma.
Blurb: Desperate times call for desperate measures in Anderson’s (a father-daughter writing team) dystopic future. As the divide between social classes rages on, succubus-like Changers are pitted against the stubborn and rebellious Punks, with malicious and benevolent Infiltrators posing threats at every turn.
by Richard Due
Plot: Idiot Genius is a whimsical novel any middle school kid would enjoy. Zany characters, imaginative settings, and a sense of adventure will appeal to young readers. They'll be eager to get their hands on the next installment.
Prose: Richard Due's prose is creative and engaging. Clever dialogue, humor, and menace make this a fun if rather long read for the target audience.
Originality: Idiot Genius is a fun, fresh read. The plot, setting, and characters are all delightfully original.
Character development: There are many colorful, interesting characters in Idiot Genius but the book focuses more on the plot and the adventure than on rounding any of them out.